Categories
Growbag Blog

The Acid Test

A trip north to Caroline’s Highland haven this week has got us thinking all over again about the importance of knowing what will grow in YOUR OWN garden soil.  A plant may look wonderful in the catalogue or on the telly, but would it turn up its toes super-quickly in your patch…….? 

Elaine

Caroline has been proudly walking me round her Scottish garden pointing out dozens of plants I can only dream of growing! She has been trying to explain that it’s because her skill set has now surpassed that of her elders and betters, but really it’s not (as if?!).  

Caroline’s garden – stuffed with treasures I couldn’t possibly grow

The soil in her garden is rich and acidic, and the soil in my garden is thin and alkaline. Ignore the pH (‘potential of Hydrogen’ ????) of your outdoor space and you may well spend much of your garden budget on plants that will loathe their new home and respond accordingly (i.e. die, most likely) . 

Happily,  I can grow a few things that would only sulk in acid soil.  Irises and lavenders are very content in my dry alkaline conditions and would hate the richness and damp of peat or clay. 

Iris ‘Langport Wren’
Iris ‘Langport Wren’ – very content in my alkaline soil

Lilac thrives almost too well on my patch. It means that I can enjoy plants like Syringa ‘Palibin’ without a qualm. 

Lilac meyeri ‘Palibin’ – so dainty, so pretty, so scented, and so happy in chalk.

Alpines enjoy alkaline soil too and of course, my beloved clematis species such as C. montana, viticella and tangutica, are happy as pigs in s***, as long as you give them some juicy rotted manure etc, round their roots at planting time.  

Another gorgeous plant for alkaline soils – Clematis viticella ‘Venosa Violacea’

Caroline

Yes, I was chuffed by Elaine’s ‘ooohs’ and ‘aaahs’ when she walked around my garden this week, and I secretly gave my burgeoning rhodies and azaleas a thumbs up as we progressed. 

Rhododendrons and azaleas just love the acidic soil of the Scottish Highlands!

Of course I kept quiet about the salvias and Dianthus at the bottom of my compost heap, and indeed the irises which have NEVER flowered for me.

To be honest I wasn’t aware of the importance of soil pH for years, I’m not someone who does instruction manuals. Instead I’ve simply planted things I fancy, and wasted £££ in the process.

As a rule of thumb most of Scotland has an acidic soil thanks to our bedrock and plentiful rain (how lucky are we?) and, very slowly, I’ve discovered the benefits of consulting the RHS’s website on soil-suitability BEFORE I buy anything, ie I now know rhododendrons, azaleas, camellias, hydrangeas and kniphofias (look at them glowing our feature pic this week!) will literally give of a ‘whoop’ when they go in my ground. 

Sadly the swift death of my acid-loving magnolias and Pieris must be put down to incompetence, and I actively dislike heathers so they won’t have the opportunity to thrive here, but I dote on my small but perfect Enkianthus, plus my stunning Aronia shrubs – both allergic to alkaline soils.

My very small but perfectly formed Enkianthus flowering for the first time. It will only grow in an acid soil ??

So while I am a little jealous of Elaine’s enormous clematis displays, I’m quite happy to stay in my lane all the while that I can revel in my exclusive ability within the family, to grow blue Himalayan poppies!

Himalayan blue poppy - Meconopsis ‘Lingholm’
It’s worth you considering a move to the Highlands to be able to grow these poppies!

Laura

Blimey – what with Caroline’s uncharacteristic grasp of geological bedrock, and Elaine’s scientific explanation of pH, my sisters have really stepped up this week!

They’re both right too; the nature of the underlying rock structure determines how many Hydrogen ions are likely to be present in the soil which in turn dictates how easily plant nutrients can be absorbed. Certain plants have evolved adaptations to cope with either strongly acidic soils or strongly alkaline ones and will fail to thrive if they are swapped into the opposite conditions.

pH runs from 1 – 14 but garden soils fall in the range of 3 – 10. 7 is neutral, and anything above 7 is alkaline and below 7 is acidic, both to varying degrees as indicated by the position of the arrow.

My garden sits on Wealden Sandstone, (another acidic bedrock Caroline!) so is also on the acid side of neutral, but being a rather more discerning gardener I have gone for a more eclectic range of ericaceous plants than the obvious rhododendron/azalea ‘fillers’.

Fothergilla is a choice plant for acid soils – cute little bottlebrush flowers in spring then this stunning autumn colour. It’s deciduous so can be under planted with spring bulbs – so much more versatile than a dwarf rhododendron!

Of course you can manipulate your soil conditions to a certain extent but because pH is a logarithmic scale and each whole pH unit represents a tenfold change in intensity, it would take an enormous quantity of lime or acidic material to shift the dial in open ground. It is, however more feasible in pots and I now grow all my tulips, wallflowers, hybrid clematis and pasque flowers (Pulsatilla) in large pots to which garden lime has been added until the pH meter registers a mildly alkaline reading- a technique that both my sisters will probably consider rather too much of a faff….

My Pulsatilla collection is much happier in pots with added lime and grit than in my acidic garden soil

So is gardening an art or a science? I think this week’s blog shows that it is a bit of both, which makes it all the more rewarding as a source of life-long learning.

We’d love to hear your experiences of picking the right (or the wrong) plant for your soil conditions ……


This week, our columnist Louise Sims is singing the praises of a truly charming late season perennial that you don’t often see for sale. Happy in sun or part-shade, it adds the pleasure of pretty flowers and beautiful foliage to the early autumn scene. No wonder it’s one of her Great Plants this Month:


Can you grow alkaline-loving plants in an acidic garden. Yes, you can if you do what Caroline does in this short video – Acid to Alkali in Caroline’s garden:


We hope we’ve convinced you this week of the value of knowing the acidity/alkalinity of your garden soil. We’ve got these really useful pH meters in our online shop – inexpensive but they could save you a lot of money in plants unsuitable for your patch!


 ? The costs of keeping our site working and safe are going up. We want to go on sharing everything for free without adverts, but if you enjoy our weekly posts, the price of a cup of coffee would be extremely helpful in paying the bills! Thank you ?

By the3growbags

We're three sisters who love gardening, plants and even the science of horticulture but we're not all experts. We'd love everyone even remotely interested in their gardens to be part of our blogsite.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.